Sunday, 22 November 2015

Response 3: De-tales




Building: PNC Bank
Location: 1100 S University Ave, Ann Arbor, MI
Type: Expressive, "Material Joint"
Scale: Component

Though its aesthetic is predominantly modern, this building is "sandwiched" by two mosaic panels consisting of green granite shards.  Each one of these granite shards is uniquely shaped but has been strategically placed so as to mimic the repetition and geometric qualities of square tiles.  This creates an interesting dynamic: it seems as though this component of the building may be stable and unstable simultaneously.  After examining the inside of the building, it becomes clear that these mosaics serve as decorative barriers that hide the important structural elements that allow the remainder of the façade to consist of mainly glass.  Finally, these granite mosaics serve to show the wealth of the bank as many prominent banks throughout history were composed of granite.  

Overall, these mosaics are in fact ornament, but they are intended to serve as visual barriers as well as to contribute to the overall feel of the building (the overall feel being the instability one might associate with a building composed of mostly glass and the wealth of the bank). 

 In reference to Frascari's article, these mosaics are primarily "material joints" as they connect different components, materials, of the building together.  Though they may initially seem to be "formal joints", it becomes clear that these mosaics do not connect the interior space to the exterior space of the building, but instead do the exact opposite- they block this connection.  A very important aspect of Frascari's article that is apparent through these mosaics is "collocation"- the significance of placement.  Of course, the placement of these mosaics serve a practical purpose (visual barriers), but they also serve a historical purpose (referencing the wealth associated with a façade consisting of granite).  Through close analysis, it is clear that this component is very important to the overall vibe of the building. 










No comments:

Post a Comment